The choices you think you can't make: boundaries, agency and alignment

Last week I caught myself saying "I can't" four times before lunch. I can't say no to that meeting. I can't leave before five. I can't take the weekend off, not with that deadline. I can't ask for help on this one.

When I went back over the list later that afternoon, cup of tea in hand, something uncomfortable surfaced. Not one of those was actually a can't. Each was a choice. Some were good choices. Some were choices I had made so many times they had stopped feeling like choices at all. And one or two were choices I had quietly handed to someone else without noticing.

That is what this post is about: the space between what we can choose, what we believe we can't, and how boundaries help us live in line with what matters.

Agency is not the same as control

Agency is your capacity to act on your own behalf: to notice what you want, to see a way towards it, and to take a step. In hope theory, Snyder described this as two partners working together: agency thinking ("I can do something here") and pathways thinking ("here are some ways I might do it"). When either one goes quiet, we feel stuck.

Agency does not mean you control everything. You don't control your workload allocation, your colleague's tone in an email, or the school pick-up time. But you nearly always have some choice in how you respond, what you agree to, what you prioritise, and what you let go of. Agency lives in that space.

The trouble is that repeated pressure can wear that space down. If you have spent years in systems that reward saying yes, you can start to experience your own choices as fixed rules. Psychologists call the extreme version of this learned helplessness. Most of us aren't there. We're somewhere in the softer middle, where "I can't" has become shorthand for "I haven't let myself consider it".

Three kinds of choices

I find it useful to sort my choices into three groups.

1. Choices you know you make. These are visible to you. You choose to go for a walk at lunch. You choose to turn off notifications after 7pm. You own them, and they usually feel steadying.

2. Choices you think you can't make. These hide behind words like have to, should, no option and that's just how it is. Some of them really are constrained. Many are choices with a cost you would rather not pay: disappointing someone, feeling guilty, looking less committed. A choice with a cost is still a choice. Naming it that way doesn't mean you have to make a different choice. It means you get to make it on purpose.

3. Choices you've handed over. These are decisions you've let someone else, or the culture around you, make for you. The default meeting time. The expectation that you'll reply on a Sunday. The idea that rest has to be earned. Handing a choice over isn't a failure. Sometimes it's efficient. But it's worth checking now and then whether you'd still hand it over if you were deciding fresh today.

Boundaries are about what you will do

Here's the reframe that changed how I think about boundaries: a boundary is not a rule for other people. It's a statement about what you will do.

"You can't email me after hours" is a request, and other people may or may not honour it. "I don't check email after 6pm, and I'll reply the next working day" is a boundary. It sits within your agency. It doesn't depend on anyone else changing.

This matters because boundaries framed as rules for others tend to leave us feeling resentful when they're crossed. Boundaries framed as our own actions leave us feeling steadier, because we're still the one choosing.

A few practical shapes a boundary can take:

  • Time: "I protect Wednesday mornings for writing."

  • Energy: "I say yes to one extra committee a year, not three."

  • Availability: "I'm not on messages over the weekend. If it's urgent, call."

  • Emotional: "I can listen, and I can't fix this for you."

  • Self-talk: "I don't call myself lazy when I rest."

That last one is easy to overlook. Some of the boundaries that matter most are the ones we hold with ourselves.

Alignment: checking your choices against your values

Alignment is what happens when your choices and your values point the same way. Misalignment is the low hum of discomfort when they don't: when you value family and keep missing dinner, or you value creativity and haven't made anything in months.

You don't fix misalignment with a grand overhaul. You fix it with small, deliberate adjustments, one choice at a time. Try this:

  1. Write down three values that matter to you right now. Not forever, just this season.

  2. List five things you did this week that took real time or energy.

  3. Draw a line from each activity to the value it serves. Some will connect easily. Some won't connect to anything.

  4. Pick one unconnected activity and ask: is this a choice I'm making, a choice I think I can't make, or a choice I've handed over?

  5. Decide one small shift. Shorten it, delegate it, renegotiate it, or keep it and make peace with why.

This isn't about cutting everything that doesn't spark joy. Some things serve values indirectly. Paperwork serves your value of reliability. A difficult conversation serves your value of honesty. The point is to know why you're doing what you're doing.

When the "can't" is real

Some constraints are real: caring responsibilities, financial pressure, health, workplace power dynamics, structural inequity. I don't want to pretend that every "I can't" is a mindset problem. That would put the whole weight of a system onto one person's shoulders.

When the constraint is real, agency can still show up in smaller ways. You might not be able to change your workload, but you might be able to name it out loud to your manager. You might not be able to take a week off, but you might be able to protect twenty minutes. Small acts of agency matter. They remind you that you are still a person with a say in your own life, even when the say is small.

And remember, you are also someone who needs tending.

Coach yourself

Take ten minutes with these. Write your answers down rather than just thinking them, because it's easier to notice patterns on paper.

  1. Where have I said "I can't" this week? Which of those are actually "I'd rather not pay the cost"?

  2. What choice have I handed over that I'd like to take back, even partly?

  3. What is one boundary I could state as something I will do, rather than something others must do?

  4. Which of my current activities feels most out of line with my values? What is one small shift I could make?

  5. What boundary do I need to hold with myself, in how I speak to myself or how I rest?

  6. When a constraint is real, where is my smallest available choice?

  7. If I trusted myself a little more, what would I choose differently tomorrow?

You don't have to answer all seven. Pick the one that made you pause. That's usually the one with something to tell you.

Next
Next

Six and a Bit Weeks: Energy, Agency and the Final Stretch